19120 N Pima Rd, Scottsdale, Arizona 85255

Gym Owners Must Know This BEFORE Hiring Fitness Coaches

Request More Information

Request More Information

By providing your number you consent to receive marketing/promotional/notification messages from ProFit. Opt-out anytime by replying STOP. Msg & Data rates may apply.

Request More Information
Gym Owners Must Know This BEFORE Hiring Fitness Coaches

The Problem with Individual Coaching and Programming

In the fitness industry, individual coaching and programming have become popular approaches for gym owners and coaches. It allows coaches to provide personalized guidance and training plans to each client, tailoring the workouts to their specific needs and goals. However, this approach also poses some significant challenges and potential drawbacks, as Tim Lyons discovered in his experience with a gym that had a similar setup.

At this gym, each coach had their own roster of clients and was responsible for creating individualized programming for their clients. While this may seem like a great way to provide personalized attention, it created a mix-match of training modalities within the gym. Each coach had their own unique style, preferences, and methods, which led to inconsistencies in training approaches. This lack of a unified culture within the gym puzzled both clients and staff and resulted in confusion and frustration.

One of the major problems with individual coaching and programming is the potential loss of revenue for the gym if a coach were to leave. When a coach builds strong relationships with their clients, those clients may develop a sense of loyalty and dependence on their coach. If that coach decides to leave the gym, they may take their clients with them, causing a significant blow to the gym's revenue. This reliance on individual coaches can create an unstable business model and make it difficult for the gym to survive in the long run.

Another issue with individual coaching is scalability. When each coach is responsible for their own roster of clients and programming, there is a limit to how many clients each coach can effectively manage. This can become problematic as the gym grows and attracts more clients. There may come a point where the demand for coaching services exceeds the capacity of the existing coaching staff, leading to overload and burnout. It also limits the potential for growth and expansion of the gym if there is a reliance on a limited number of coaches.

To address these challenges, gym owners and coaches need to shift their focus towards building a unified culture and implementing a more structured approach to coaching and programming. Rather than having each coach create their own individualized programming, there should be a standardized approach that all coaches follow. This promotes consistency and allows for easy collaboration and communication between coaches and clients.

Additionally, gym owners should prioritize building strong relationships between clients and the gym itself, rather than solely relying on individual coaches. By creating a sense of community and a strong brand identity, clients will feel connected to the gym as a whole and will be less likely to follow a coach if they were to leave. This reduces the risk of losing clients and helps to stabilize the revenue stream for the gym.

Furthermore, implementing scalable systems and processes is essential for long-term success. This can include hiring additional coaches to meet the increasing demand, creating training protocols that all coaches can follow, and investing in technology solutions that streamline administrative tasks and allow for efficient client management.

In conclusion, while individual coaching and programming have their benefits, they also come with several challenges that need to be addressed. Gym owners and coaches should focus on establishing a unified culture, building strong relationships with clients, and implementing scalable systems to ensure long-term success and stability for their gyms.

The Risks Faced by Gym Owners

In this blog post, we will discuss the various risks faced by gym owners in the decentralized coaching model. Gym owners play a crucial role in creating a conducive environment for coaches and clients, but they also shoulder a significant amount of risk and potential financial consequences.

One of the primary risks faced by gym owners is the freedom coaches have to leave and start up at another gym. Unlike traditional employment models, coaches in a decentralized coaching setup are not bound by contracts or enforceable commitments. While this freedom enables coaches to explore different opportunities, it puts gym owners at a disadvantage because they invest time, resources, and trust in training these coaches.

Imagine a scenario where a gym owner invests several months in training a coach only for them to leave and join a competitor gym. Apart from losing a valuable member of the coaching staff, the gym owner also faces the potential loss of clients who may choose to follow the coach to the new gym. This can have a significant impact on the gym's reputation and revenue.

During a recent coaching call, Tim shared his experience with new clients who had already faced this problem twice before taking ownership of the gym. They had lost a considerable amount of recurring revenue, roughly $20,000, as a result. These losses not only affected the financial stability of the gym but also created a sense of uncertainty among the existing clients.

To mitigate the risks associated with coaches leaving, gym owners can consider implementing strategies such as non-compete agreements or financial incentives to encourage coaches to stay. However, despite these measures, gym owners may still face unforeseen challenges when coaches decide to move on.

Another risk faced by gym owners in the decentralized coaching model is the potential impact on the gym's reputation. When a coach leaves a gym, clients who have developed a rapport with that coach may choose to follow them. This can lead to a loss of clients and a decrease in recurring revenue.

Furthermore, if a coach leaves on bad terms or starts a new gym in the vicinity, it can create a negative perception of the original gym. Clients may question the reasons behind the coach's departure and doubt the stability and quality of the gym's services. This can make it challenging to attract new clients and maintain the loyalty of existing ones.

While gym owners in a decentralized coaching model face these risks, it is essential to recognize that this model also offers certain benefits. Coaches have the freedom to experiment with different training techniques, explore new business opportunities, and serve a diverse range of clients. This flexibility can contribute to professional growth and innovation within the fitness industry.

In conclusion, gym owners in the decentralized coaching model face significant risks and potential financial consequences. The freedom coaches have to leave and start up at another gym can lead to the loss of valuable staff members and clients, affecting the gym's reputation and revenue. However, with proper risk mitigation strategies and a focus on maintaining a strong relationship with clients, gym owners can navigate these challenges and thrive in the ever-evolving fitness industry.

The Solution: Unified Programming and Shared Clientele

When it comes to running a successful gym, Tim has a unique solution in mind - unified programming and shared clientele. He firmly believes that this approach can provide more protection for gym owners while also fostering a sense of unity among the clients.

According to Tim, the programming of a gym should come from the top-down, with the gym itself taking the lead in designing and implementing workout plans. This way, clients would have consistent experiences regardless of which coach they work with.

One of the key benefits of this setup is that it offers more protection for gym owners. By centralizing the programming, it becomes less dependent on individual coaches. This means that even if a coach decides to leave, the gym can continue to provide the same high-quality service to its clients.

Furthermore, unified programming also creates a sense of unity and cohesion among clients. When everyone is following the same workout plans and being held to the same standards, it creates a shared experience and culture within the gym. Clients can connect with one another, share their progress, and support each other in their fitness journeys.

Tim also emphasizes that coaches should be seen as tools with different skill sets. Each coach brings their own unique background and expertise to the table, and clients can benefit from working with different coaches over time. This not only helps clients gain a broader perspective on fitness but also ensures that they receive well-rounded training.

By shifting the focus from individual coaches to the gym brand, Tim believes that the value provided to clients becomes more consistent and reliable. Clients should choose a gym based on the gym's reputation and the quality of its programming, rather than solely focusing on an individual coach.

Implementing unified programming and shared clientele may require some adjustments and coordination within the gym. However, the benefits far outweigh the initial challenges. Gym owners gain a greater level of control and stability over their business, while clients benefit from a unified experience and access to a broader range of expertise.

Overall, Tim's solution of unified programming and shared clientele presents a compelling approach to running a successful gym. By prioritizing the gym brand and offering consistent programming across all coaches, gym owners can create a thriving and supportive environment for their clients.

The Risks of Misclassifying Trainers as 1099 Contractors Instead of W-2 Employees

Proper employee classification is a crucial aspect of running a business, especially when it comes to trainers in the fitness industry. Many gym owners, in an attempt to reduce costs and administrative burdens, misclassify their trainers as 1099 contractors instead of W-2 employees. However, this practice can lead to significant risks and legal consequences.

Understanding the Differences

Before delving into the risks of misclassification, it is important to understand the differences between 1099 contractors and W-2 employees. A 1099 contractor is considered self-employed and is responsible for paying their own taxes, obtaining their own insurance, and maintaining control over their work schedule and methods. On the other hand, a W-2 employee is hired by the company, receives benefits, and has taxes withheld from their pay.

The Potential Legal Consequences

Misclassifying trainers as 1099 contractors when they should be considered W-2 employees can have serious legal ramifications. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and state labor agencies actively target companies that misclassify employees, as it results in lost tax revenue. If found guilty of misclassification, gym owners may face penalties, fines, and even criminal charges.

In addition to the financial implications, misclassified trainers can also pursue legal action to claim the benefits and rights they are entitled to as W-2 employees. This can include back pay, unpaid overtime, and access to employee benefits such as health insurance and retirement plans.

A Real-Life Example

To illustrate the potential consequences of misclassification, let's consider the story of a gym owner who misclassified their trainers. This gym owner, who we will refer to as John, believed that classifying his trainers as 1099 contractors would save him money.

However, one of John's trainers eventually realized that they were being misclassified and sought legal advice. The trainer, with the help of an employment attorney, was able to prove that they should have been classified as a W-2 employee all along. As a result, John was required to pay over $40,000 in back pay, unpaid overtime, and penalties.

Double-Check Your Classification

Given the potential risks and legal consequences, it is essential for gym owners to double-check their employee classification and make changes if necessary. Consultation with an employment attorney or tax professional can provide guidance in ensuring compliance with employment laws.

Here are a few factors to consider when determining the appropriate classification for your trainers:

  1. Control: If you have significant control over your trainers' work schedule, methods, and performance, they are likely employees rather than contractors.
  2. Independence: If your trainers have the freedom to work for other gyms or clients and have their own business, they may be classified as contractors. However, be cautious and ensure that this independence is genuine.
  3. Integration: If the trainers are integral to your gym's operations and are not providing a separate service, they are more likely to be classified as employees.

Avoiding Legal Issues

To avoid legal issues related to employee misclassification, it is crucial to make the necessary changes to ensure compliance with employment laws. This may involve reclassifying trainers as W-2 employees and properly documenting employment relationships.

Additionally, it is important to maintain accurate records of hours worked, payment details, and any agreements made with trainers. Regular audits and reviews of employment practices can help identify any potential misclassifications and allow for appropriate corrective measures.


Misclassifying trainers as 1099 contractors instead of W-2 employees is a risky practice that can lead to significant legal and financial consequences. Gym owners must understand the differences between the classifications and ensure proper employee classification to avoid potential legal issues. By taking proactive measures and seeking professional advice when needed, gym owners can protect themselves and their trainers from the risks associated with misclassification.

Seeking Help and Taking Action

Transitioning to a shared clientele and implementing a top-down programming approach can be a challenging process for gym owners. However, Tim understands the importance of seeking help and support during this time of change. He encourages gym owners to reach out and ask for assistance if they need it.

Recognizing that every gym is unique and may require different strategies for success, Tim offers a coaching program specifically designed to support gym owners in making these important changes. This program provides personalized guidance and advice, tailored to the specific needs of each individual gym owner.

By participating in Tim's coaching program, gym owners can gain valuable insights and expertise that will help them successfully navigate the transition to a shared clientele and top-down programming. Tim understands that gym owners have invested time, energy, and resources into building their businesses, and he is dedicated to helping them protect and grow their investments.

One of the key benefits of Tim's coaching program is the opportunity to learn from his own experiences and successes in implementing a shared clientele and top-down programming approach. Tim has firsthand knowledge of the challenges and obstacles that gym owners may face, as well as the strategies and solutions that can lead to long-term success.

In addition to offering guidance and support, Tim also emphasizes the importance of taking action. Transitioning to a shared clientele and implementing a top-down programming approach requires proactivity and a willingness to make necessary changes. Tim encourages all gym owners to take the necessary steps to ensure the long-term success and sustainability of their businesses.

The fitness industry is constantly evolving, and gym owners must be willing to adapt in order to thrive in this competitive market. Tim believes that taking action and making the necessary changes is crucial for gym owners to stay ahead of the curve and meet the needs of their clients.

While the process of change may seem daunting, Tim's coaching program provides gym owners with the support, knowledge, and resources they need to successfully transition to a shared clientele and top-down programming approach. By seeking help and taking action, gym owners can position themselves for long-term success and ensure the continued growth of their gyms.

So, if you're a gym owner who is considering transitioning to a shared clientele and top-down programming, don't hesitate to seek help and support. Reach out to Tim and take advantage of his coaching program to guide you through this transformative process. Remember, the success of your gym is in your hands.

Built To Grow Podcast

Catch up with the latest episode

Request information

Request Information Now!

Business Coaching near Scottsdale

Let us e-mail you this Free Report

Take our free quiz: How Strong is my Fitness Business?

click here to take the quiz